It turns our that there is a error in Hw3. In problem 6 it is *not* possible to prove the first set unsatisfiable by input resolution. So please modify the set as follows and do the problem with the new set. Replace the last closure (R(x_4), R(y_4) ->).{} by (R(x_4) -> Q(y_4)).{y_4 = x_4} Thanks to Colin who pointed the problem out, and sorry for any inconvenience. -CT